Lakmé Eyeconic vs Maybelline Colossal Kajal: Which Suits You?
Lakmé Eyeconic or Maybelline Colossal? Compare claims, shades, waterline safety and smudge-proofing on oily lids, plus gentle removal and sensitive-eye options.

Choose Maybelline The Colossal Kajal 24HR if you want one deep black kajal whose main product page clearly says it is ophthalmologically tested. Choose Lakmé Eyeconic Kajal if you want more shade choice (brown, white and bright colours as well as black) or the cooling Insta Cool version. Both are twist-up, waterproof, smudge-proof kajal pencils the brands say last up to 24 hours, so on oily lids in humid weather, how you apply each one matters as much as which one you buy.
This guide compares the two formulas using the brands’ own India websites and major retailer listings. GlowVibe has not wear-tested either kajal. Below: the claims, the ingredients, who each suits, and how to stop smudging, remove kajal and protect sensitive eyes.
Quick verdict
- Pick Maybelline The Colossal Kajal 24HR if you want a single intense black, like the ophthalmologically tested claim on the main product page, and like soothing-sounding extras such as aloe vera and vitamins C and E in the formula.
- Pick Lakmé Eyeconic Kajal if you want a softer brown for daytime, a white pencil to brighten the waterline, or a coloured kajal (blues and greens) for festive and wedding looks.
- Pick Lakmé Eyeconic Insta Cool Kajal if you like a cooling feel on the lash line. Lakmé says it contains cucumber seed extract and is ophthalmologically tested.
- Skip both on the waterline if you have sensitive or dry eyes, wear contact lenses and often get irritation, or have an eye infection. Keep any kajal on the outer lash line instead.
Lakmé Eyeconic vs Maybelline Colossal kajal: side-by-side
The table below uses what each brand states on its India website. Some retailers list Lakmé at 22 hours, so read your pack.
| Feature | Lakmé Eyeconic Kajal | Maybelline The Colossal Kajal 24HR |
|---|---|---|
| Format | Twist-up pencil, 0.35 g | Twist-up pencil |
| Wear claim | Up to 24 hours (brand site) | Up to 24 hours (brand site) |
| Waterproof / smudge-proof | The brand says yes to both | The brand says yes to both |
| Eye-safety claim | Not stated on the main Eyeconic Kajal page; Lakmé says variants such as Insta Cool and 9-5 Eyeconic Smokey are ophthalmologically tested | Ophthalmologically tested, per the brand |
| Notable ingredients | SiliconesIngredients like dimethicone that coat hair (and skin) for slip, shine and frizz control. Heavier ones can build up and need a clarifying wash.See glossaryRead the guide and wax base with grape seed oil | Aloe vera, Vitamin CAn antioxidant that brightens dull skin, helps fade the look of dark spots and supports sunscreen against daily damage. Best used in the morning.See glossaryRead the guide and Vitamin E (tocopherol)An antioxidant and moisturising ingredient. It is often paired with vitamin C to make it more stable.See glossary, with what Maybelline calls a deep black mineral colour |
| Shade range | Black, Classic Brown, Sparkling Black, White and several blues and greens (availability varies) | Black |
| Best for | Shade variety, softer daytime looks, colour play | One deep black line for everyday and party wear |
Formulas, names and claims change from time to time, so check the current label and ingredient list before you buy, especially if you have sensitive eyes.
Maybelline The Colossal Kajal 24HR: what it is built for
Maybelline India lists this pencil as The Colossal Kajal 24HR. The brand says it gives an intense black in one stroke and stays smudge-proof and waterproof for up to 24 hours. It describes an “Intense Black Fix Formula” with a deep black mineral colour, enriched with aloe vera, vitamin C and vitamin E.
The brand says the formula is ophthalmologically tested.
Who it suits: anyone who wants one reliable, very dark black and doesn’t need colours. Who should skip it: people who prefer a softer brown for office or daytime looks, and anyone who has reacted to it before.
Lakmé Eyeconic Kajal: what it is built for
Lakmé India currently lists the core pencil as Lakmé Eyeconic Kajal with Intense Pigments, Waterproof, 24 Hour Wear, in 0.35 g. The brand says it gives an intense, deep colour in a single swipe with a waterproof, smudge-proof formula. The listed ingredients include cyclopentasiloxane (a silicone that helps it glide and then set), polyethylene, polybutene, microcrystalline wax and grape seed oil.
The big difference is choice. Lakmé lists Black, Classic Brown, Sparkling Black, White, Forest Green, Turquoise, Regal Green, Royal Blue and Midnight Blue, though not every shade is in stock at once. Lakmé also sells the Eyeconic Insta Cool Kajal in Deep Black, which it says has cucumber seed extract for a cooling feel, lasts up to 22 hours and is ophthalmologically tested.
Who it suits: people who switch between brown for work, black for evenings and colour for festive outfits. Who should skip it: anyone who wants an ophthalmologically tested claim written on the exact pencil they use. Look at the pack, because the claim differs across Eyeconic versions.
Smudge and wear on oily lids and in humidity
Both brands make the same promise: waterproof and smudge-proof for up to 24 hours. Treat that as a best case. Lakmé’s own FAQ notes that results vary with application, water and rubbing. Independent reviews are mixed, which is normal for any kajal worn on oily skin.

In Indian weather, smudging has little to do with the brand. The skin around your eyes makes oil, and sweat and humidity add moisture. Both soften the waxes in a pencil. Tears and blinking push colour from the waterline onto the lower lash line. If you have oily lids, expect some fading by evening from either pencil,.
Intensity: which looks darker?
Both brands say you get intense black colour in one stroke. Lakmé’s Sparkling Black adds shimmer, so it reads less flat than a matte black. For the darkest possible line, set either black with a black eyeshadow pressed on top (method below). For office wear, Lakmé’s Classic Brown is gentler.
Waterline use and eye safety
Kajal on the waterline is a big part of Indian makeup, but it carries the most risk. Your waterline sits just beside the oil glands that keep your tears healthy. A small study by eye researchers found that eyeliner applied on the waterline moved into the tear film faster and in larger amounts than liner applied outside the lashes.
What “ophthalmologically tested” really means
It means the product was tested on people under an eye doctor’s supervision. It is a good sign, and it is why choosing a branded kajal is safer than unbranded or homemade kajal and surma. Health regulators, including the US FDA, have warned that some traditional kohl and surma products contain lead. Still, the claim is not a guarantee for your eyes, so stop using any kajal that stings, makes your eyes red or leaves them watering.
Hygiene rules for any kajal
- Never share kajal, not even with a sister or friend at a wedding. Eye pencils can carry bacteria and viruses, including those behind conjunctivitis.
- Wipe the tip. Twist-ups can’t be sharpened, so wipe the tip with a clean tissue after each use and twist up only a little.
- Check the expiry. Lakmé states 36 months from manufacture for the unopened Eyeconic Kajal. Once opened, follow the open-jar symbol on the pack and replace sooner if the texture, smell or colour changes.
- Throw it out after an eye infection. Use a new pencil once your eyes have fully healed.
- Contact lens wearers: put lenses in before makeup, take them out before removal, and keep kajal off the waterline if you notice grit or blur.
How to stop kajal from smudging
- Keep under-eye cream light. Put on eye cream at least 10 minutes before makeup, or save it for night. Blot the eye area with a tissue before you line.
- Prime the lids. Dab a thin layer of eyeshadow primer or a dry concealer over the lids and just under the lower lashes. If you choose a primer, pick a light one; our guide to water-based vs oil-based primer explains why water-based suits oily skin better.
- Powder under the eyes. Press a little translucent powder under the lower lash line. This soaks up oil that would otherwise drag the colour down.
- Line with your eyes slightly open. Look up into a mirror and draw one slow stroke along the lower lash line. Most smudging starts on the waterline, so line it lightly or skip it.
- Let it set for 30 seconds. Keep your eyes open and don’t blink hard while the formula sets.
- Lock it with shadow. Press a matte black or dark brown eyeshadow over the line with a thin brush.
- Touch up, don’t pile on. If the colour fades, wipe the smudge away with a cotton bud, blot, and add one fresh stroke.
A shiny base under the eyes is one of the classic everyday makeup mistakes that make kajal smudge. If you wear foundation on an oily face, setting it well helps your eye makeup too; our Lakmé vs Maybelline foundation for oily skin comparison covers the base routine.

How to remove waterproof kajal gently
Waterproof kajal is made to resist water, so plain face wash usually leaves a grey ring. Lakmé itself recommends a gentle eye makeup remover and says oil-based removers work well on its long-wear formula.
- Soak a cotton pad in a bi-phase or oil-based eye makeup remover, or a cleansing oil.
- Hold it on your closed eye for 15 to 20 seconds so the wax softens.
- Wipe gently outwards. Don’t scrub side to side.
- Use a cotton bud dipped in remover for the waterline, with your eye looking up.
- Follow with your usual face wash to rinse away the oil.
The same removers that dissolve waterproof mascara work on kajal; see our gentle mascara remover picks for options that are kind to the eye area. Never sleep in kajal, especially on the waterline.
Alternatives for sensitive eyes
If kajal makes your eyes water, itch or turn red, try these, one at a time:
- Move it outside the lashes. Line only the outer lash line, not the waterline.
- Use eyeshadow as liner. A dark brown or black matte powder shadow pressed along the lashes with a damp angled brush has fewer waxes and silicones.
- Choose a Fragrance-freeA product with no added perfume or essential oils for scent. Often the safer pick for sensitive or reactive skin. "Unscented" can still contain masking fragrance.See glossary, ophthalmologically tested pencil and check the label for any ingredient you have reacted to before.
- Go softer. A brown pencil like Lakmé’s Classic Brown shows less smudging than jet black when it does move.
- Avoid homemade or unbranded kajal and surma. They are not tested for purity, and some traditional kohl has been found to contain lead.
Before you wear a new pencil to an event, test it on the outer lash line for a few hours at home. If your eyes stay red, painful or blurry after you remove it, see an eye doctor.
Can you use both?
Yes, and lots of people do. A practical split is Lakmé Eyeconic Kajal in Classic Brown for office days and Maybelline The Colossal Kajal 24HR for a deep black at parties and weddings. You can also layer them: line with black, then trace a coloured Lakmé shade like Royal Blue just below it for a festive outfit.
Common kajal mistakes
- Putting on kajal straight after a rich under-eye cream.
- Going over the waterline again and again through the day instead of cleaning and redoing it.
- Rubbing eyes with your fingers, which spreads kajal and germs.
- Sharing a pencil at a function or using a tester on the waterline in a shop.

Frequently Asked Questions
Both brands make the same waterproof, smudge-proof, 24-hour claim, so neither is clearly better on oily lids. Your prep matters more: blot, prime, powder under the eyes and set the line with eyeshadow. Choose by shade and eye-safety claim instead.
Maybelline says The Colossal Kajal 24HR is ophthalmologically tested and shows lining the lower lash line. Any pencil on the waterline can still irritate some eyes or mix into tears. If you notice stinging, redness or grittiness, keep it outside the lashes.
Lakmé says some Eyeconic variants, including Insta Cool and 9-5 Eyeconic Smokey Kajal, are ophthalmologically tested. The main Eyeconic Kajal page on Lakmé India does not state it, and one Lakmé retail listing calls the black pencil dermatologically tested. Read the claim on the pack you buy.
Follow the open-jar symbol on the pack and the expiry date. Lakmé lists 36 months from manufacture for Eyeconic Kajal. Replace any pencil sooner if it smells odd, changes texture or after an eye infection.
Waterproof means it resists water and tears, but skin oil, eye cream and rubbing still break it down. Humidity speeds that up. Powder under the eyes and a shadow layer on top usually fixes most of it.
Quick poll
How much do you usually spend on one beauty product?
The bottom line
Lakmé Eyeconic and Maybelline Colossal are closer than the ads suggest: both are twist-up, waterproof, smudge-proof pencils with 24-hour claims. Pick Maybelline for one deep black with a clear ophthalmologically tested claim, and Lakmé for brown, white and colour options or the cooling Insta Cool version. Then prep your lids, go easy on the waterline, never share your pencil, and take it all off gently every night.
